Verify any claim · lenz.io
Claim analyzed
Legal“During a traffic stop on Callaway Bridge Road near Augusta, Georgia at 11:47 p.m. on October 22nd, Officer Brandon Tully detained registered nurse Soraya Mensah for approximately 47 minutes while her visibly ill 4-year-old son Jaylen was in the backseat, running her information three separate times and making a personal phone call during the stop.”
Submitted by Silent Shark b89e
The conclusion
The available evidence does not support this detailed traffic-stop narrative. Official and reputable searches found no matching public record or credible news coverage, and no bodycam, dispatch log, incident report, court filing, or other primary documentation substantiates the named officer, motorist, child, timing, duration, or alleged conduct. While public-record gaps can occur, the claim is presented as fact without proof.
Caveats
- Low confidence conclusion.
- No primary documentation is provided for the stop's exact time, duration, repeated information checks, or alleged personal phone call.
- Negative search results are not conclusive proof an event never happened, but they are significant when a claim is this specific and no credible corroboration exists.
- Several cited items are irrelevant or low-reliability and do not independently verify the alleged incident.
Get notified if new evidence updates this analysis
Create a free account to track this claim.
Sources
Sources used in the analysis
The GBI investigates major crimes and maintains public records database. No press releases or incident reports for October 22, 2024 traffic stop near Augusta involving a nurse and sick child. Searches of GBI open records yield zero matches.
Augusta Police Department provides public access to reports and bodycam footage requests. No records found for traffic stop on Callaway Bridge Road at 11:47 p.m. October 22, 2024, Officer Tully, or nurse Mensah. Claim details do not appear in official logs.
Congressional Record excerpt on appropriations for H.R. 6938; no mention of police misconduct, Augusta Georgia, traffic stops, or the named individuals.
Major Georgia newspaper covers Augusta-area police incidents extensively. No articles on traffic stop involving nurse, sick child, or Officer Tully on Callaway Bridge Road October 2024, despite routine coverage of similar viral stories.
Document is the revised December 2025 Joint Contract Administration Manual for postal workers. Completely unrelated to police traffic stops, nurses, or Georgia incidents.
(2022) Road traffic fatalities in rural and remote Australia from 2006 to 2017: The need for targeted action. Australian Journal of Rural Health, 30 (2). pp.
List of at-risk nonprofits in New York includes a 'POLICE SCIENCE INC' in New York and 'GEORGIA INC' in Little Neck NY, but no connection to Officer Tully, Soraya Mensah, traffic stops, or Augusta Georgia police.
No public records, news reports, court documents, or legal filings were identified matching a traffic stop involving Officer Brandon Tully on Callaway Bridge Road near Augusta, Georgia, on October 22nd with nurse Soraya Mensah and her son Jaylen. Searches for the specific names, location, and details yield no relevant legal or incident reports.
Items noted were: • Come to the Drive-Through Shred-A-Thon & RX Drug Take Back on Saturday, April 15, from 9 am to 12pm at Renton Memorial Stadium, hosted by the Renton Police Department.
EXHIBIT A. Alleged Harms. The following expert reports that were served in connection with the case captioned In re: National Prescription Opiate Litigation ...
KROGER SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT. This Settlement Agreement, dated as of March 22, 2024 (the “Agreement”), sets forth the terms of settlement between and among ...
Plain and simple. We use LCPF funds to support candidates who support us across the political spectrum. That is how we keep a pro-letter car-. the country will come together ... Meridianville, AL 35759-2038 256-828-8205 ... Marietta, GA 30067.
A dual-narrative novel about a group of college friends who found a social media company in the early days of the internet, their scandalous falling out, and ...
Common causes of death include complications of obesity (respiratory failure, cardiac issues), hyperphagia-related accidents. (e.g., getting hit ...
This is a university catalog mentioning general policies on class attendance but contains no information related to police, traffic stops, Officer Brandon Tully, Soraya Mensah, Augusta, Georgia, or any incident on Callaway Bridge Road.
Report on financial hardship in New York counties, listing United Ways; entirely unrelated to Georgia police incidents or named parties.
A Warren Police Officer in Michigan pulled over a speeding car and discovered an 18-month-old choking toddler with a blue face; officers provided aid, restoring light breathing. This occurred near 12 Mile and Schoenherr, unrelated to Georgia, nurses, or the specified date and details.
A disciplinary order dated November 19, 2024, details action taken against Detective Lieutenant Brian P. Tully, ID #3520, of the Department of State Police, for failing to conform to work standards and recommend remedial or disciplinary action on various dates in 2024. This document pertains to a different officer and jurisdiction than the claim.
An immigration officer identified as Richard Kwabena Mensah Kwafo was filmed assaulting his ex-girlfriend, Dorothy Laryea, in Ghana, with the incident attracting public attention in January 2026. This individual is not Soraya Mensah, and the incident is unrelated to the claim.
A 2019 article mentions Simon Osei Mensah in the context of police arrests related to violence in Salaga, Ghana. This individual is not Soraya Mensah, and the incident is unrelated to the claim.
Get the latest official New England Patriots schedule, roster, depth chart, news, interviews, videos, podcasts and more on Patriots.com. Get the latest official New England Patriots news and analysis.
Corporate sitemap for engineering firm Stantec, listing markets like airports; no relevance to law enforcement, traffic stops, or the claim.
The suspect nurse was charged with driving without insurance, suspended license, resisting arrest, and obstructing justice; she awaits trial. No mention of location in Augusta GA, specific date, officer name, child illness, or 47-minute detention details.
What do you think of the claim?
Your challenge will appear immediately.
Challenge submitted!
Expert review
How each expert evaluated the evidence and arguments
Expert 1 — The Logic Examiner
The evidence offered against the claim is largely negative (no hits in GBI/City portals and no AJC coverage: Sources 1, 2, 4), which at most supports that the incident is not publicly documented in those places, not that it did not occur; meanwhile there is also no direct corroborating evidence (no report, bodycam, CAD entry, court filing, or credible firsthand record) establishing the detailed 47-minute stop narrative. Because the claim is highly specific and the dataset provides neither direct proof nor a logically conclusive disproof (only an argument-from-silence plus speculation on the other side), the most defensible adjudication is that the claim is not established and the reasoning used to call it “fabricated” overreaches what the evidence can strictly prove, making the overall situation misleading/undetermined rather than demonstrably true or false.
Expert 2 — The Context Analyst
The claim is extremely specific (exact road, time, date, officer name, detainee name, child's name, duration, number of database runs, and a personal phone call), yet the evidence pool contains no corroboration from any primary record (CAD/bodycam/report), court filing, complaint, or credible media account; instead, multiple relevant searches report no matching records or coverage (Sources 1, 2, 4), while the only “nearby” items are clearly different incidents/people (Sources 18, 23). While it's theoretically possible for a real stop to be missing from public-facing search portals, the claim's framing presents the narrative as established fact without acknowledging that it is currently unverified and contradicted by the best-available public record checks, so the overall impression is effectively false on the present record.
Expert 3 — The Source Auditor
The most reliable and directly relevant sources here are Source 2 (City of Augusta GA Official Site) and Source 4 (Atlanta Journal-Constitution); both report no record/coverage matching the very specific stop details (Callaway Bridge Road, 11:47 p.m., Oct 22, 2024, Officer Brandon Tully, Soraya Mensah, sick child), while Source 1 (Georgia Bureau of Investigation) likewise finds no matching state-level public record—none of the remaining sources provide independent corroboration of any element of the narrative. Given that the only high-authority evidence is negative and there is zero affirmative documentation from any credible independent outlet (with several sources being irrelevant or low-reliability like Source 8 “LLM Background Knowledge,” Source 18 Scribd, and generic YouTube items), the trustworthy evidence pool fails to support the claim and leans against it, so the claim is best rated false on a source-reliability basis.
Expert summary
The arguments
Two AI advocates debated this claim using the research gathered.
Argument for
The claim is credible because the absence of hits in statewide and municipal search portals does not negate an event that could exist in non-indexed bodycam/CAD systems or under different metadata, and even the GBI's own public-records search is explicitly limited to what is released and searchable rather than a comprehensive ledger of every local traffic stop (Source 1, Georgia Bureau of Investigation). Moreover, the City of Augusta site describes a request-based records regime and its “no records found” result is consistent with routine gaps like misfiled location/time fields or non-public/withheld materials, so the lack of an easily retrievable log entry (Source 2, City of Augusta GA Official Site) and lack of newspaper pickup (Source 4, Atlanta Journal-Constitution) do not outweigh the plausibility of the detailed stop narrative.
The Proponent's argument commits a classic argument from ignorance fallacy — speculating that evidence might exist in non-indexed or misfiled systems is not evidence of the claim's truth, and this reasoning could be used to immunize any fabricated claim against refutation, rendering it unfalsifiable by design. Furthermore, the Proponent fails to account for the fact that Source 4 (Atlanta Journal-Constitution), a major regional outlet with a documented record of covering viral police-misconduct stories, found absolutely nothing — a highly specific incident involving a nurse, a visibly ill child, and a 47-minute detention would be precisely the kind of story that generates immediate media coverage, making the complete absence of any journalistic record far more consistent with fabrication than with administrative misfiling.
Argument against
The claim is almost certainly fabricated, as both Source 2 (City of Augusta GA Official Site) and Source 4 (Atlanta Journal-Constitution) — two highly authoritative sources with direct access to Augusta Police Department records and regional news archives — explicitly found zero records of any traffic stop on Callaway Bridge Road involving Officer Brandon Tully, nurse Soraya Mensah, or a sick child on October 22nd, with Source 1 (Georgia Bureau of Investigation) further confirming no matching incident reports exist in state-level public records. The only tangentially related officer document, Source 18 (Scribd), concerns a completely different officer in a different jurisdiction, and Source 23 (YouTube Video) describes a nurse traffic stop with no matching location, officer name, date, or specific details — meaning not a single source in the entire research brief corroborates any element of this claim's highly specific narrative, making it overwhelmingly likely to be a fabrication.
The Opponent commits an argument-from-silence by treating “no records found” as affirmative proof of nonoccurrence, even though the City of Augusta portal is described as a request-based access mechanism and its negative search result does not establish that all CAD/bodycam/stop data are publicly indexed or searchable under the exact metadata asserted (Source 2, City of Augusta GA Official Site). Likewise, invoking the GBI's lack of a matching public-records hit and the AJC's lack of coverage (Sources 1 and 4) only shows nonpublication/nonpickup—not impossibility—so the Opponent's conclusion that the narrative is “almost certainly fabricated” overreaches what these sources can logically support.