Claim analyzed

Tech

“Most viewers or followers of the social-media account named "Cockroach Janta Party" are located in India.”

Submitted by Keen Parrot 727b

Misleading
5/10

Available reporting points toward an India-majority audience, but the claim is stated too definitively. The main evidence is a private Instagram Insights recording supplied by the account's founder, and outside observers cannot independently verify country-by-country follower data. Because rival screenshots are also unverified, the strongest accurate conclusion is that the claim is plausible, not confirmed.

Caveats

  • Country-level follower analytics on Instagram and X are not publicly auditable; only account admins can directly see them.
  • The strongest numerical support comes from a self-interested source, and news reports citing it do not independently verify the underlying platform data.
  • Indian-focused content and Hindi-language posts suggest the likely audience, but they cannot by themselves prove where most followers are located.

Sources

Sources used in the analysis

#1
Instagram Help Center 2023-11-02 | About Instagram Insights
NEUTRAL

Instagram Insights gives creators and businesses information about their followers, including top locations, age ranges and gender. These insights are only available to the account’s own administrators inside the app and are not publicly accessible for other users’ accounts.

#2
X Developer Platform 2022-09-09 | Twitter IDs and object data
NEUTRAL

Through the Twitter API, developers can retrieve public information about accounts and tweets. The API does not expose private analytics such as follower locations, age, or gender. Location data for followers is at best inferred from self‑reported profile locations, which are optional, free‑text, and often inaccurate or missing.

#3
India Today 2026-05-22 | Cockroach Janta Party and Abhijeet Dipke face Pakistan charge
SUPPORT

Calling it "Pakistan Janta Party", Bagga on Friday shared data of what he claimed was the Cockroach party's country-wise Instagram followers. It showed that citizens from Pakistan (49%), the US (14%), and Bangladesh (14%) accounted for 77% of the party's Instagram followers. As per the data, India was in fourth spot, with just 9% follower count. ... As allegations came thick and fast, Dipke, a Boston University graduate, shared the "real data". It showed that people from India accounted for 94% of CJP's Instagram followers, followed by the US (1%) and the UK (0.7%). ... So far, neither Meta nor Instagram has released any official data.

#4
The Economic Times 2025-05-23 | Cockroach Janta Party has nearly 80% followers from Pakistan, Bangladesh and Turkey, claim netizens; potential bot activity suspected
REFUTE

The article reports that social media users are alleging that a large share of the Cockroach Janata Party (CJP) Instagram account’s followers are outside India: “One user on X claimed, ‘Citizens from Pakistan, Bangladesh & USA forms 77% of their Insta followers. India contributes only 9%.’ … Another netizen wrote: ‘The CJP’s Instagram followers — roughly 63% of them are from Pakistan and Bangladesh. Only 9% are from India…’ The article notes that ‘No independent evidence supporting these figures or claims has been publicly produced’ and adds that ‘neither Meta nor Instagram has released any official data regarding the geographical distribution of the account’s followers.’

#5
India Today 2024-05-05 | What is Cockroach Janta Party and why its X account was withheld in India?
SUPPORT

According to India Today’s tech desk, the ‘Cockroach Janta Party’ started as a satirical meme page about Indian politics and went viral during the 2024 Lok Sabha elections. The content largely revolves around Indian political parties, Indian election memes and uses Hindi phrases, indicating that its primary audience is Indian social media users. The report, however, does not include platform-verified data indicating what percentage of the account’s followers are located in India versus abroad.

#6
X Help Center 2023-11-02 | About geographic analytics and audience insights
REFUTE

X (formerly Twitter) explains how audience insights are calculated: geographic breakdowns of followers are provided only to account owners through internal analytics. These stats are not publicly available for third-party viewing for specific accounts. Therefore, any public claim about the precise country-level distribution of followers for accounts such as ‘Cockroach Janta Party’ cannot be independently verified using X’s public data tools.

#7
India Today 2025-05-24 | Cockroach Janata Party Instagram page founder reveals purpose of viral account
SUPPORT

India Today quotes Abhijeet Dipke on the issue of where the page’s followers come from: “Reacting to viral posts claiming that most of the Cockroach Janata Party’s followers are from Pakistan and Bangladesh, Dipke said this was ‘misinformation’ and that ‘nearly 94 per cent’ of the followers are from India, based on his own Instagram analytics.” The report adds that India Today “was not able to independently verify the geo-location of the account’s followers, and Meta did not respond to questions on the subject at the time of publication.”

#8
India Today 2026-05-23 | Fact Check: Is Pakistan the biggest following of Cockroach Janta Party’s Instagram account?
SUPPORT

India Today’s Fact Check desk investigated the viral claim that Pakistan constitutes nearly half of the followers of the Cockroach Janta Party’s Instagram account. The screenshot shared by Tajinder Pal Singh Bagga could not be independently verified and appeared to be inconsistent with other metrics. On the other hand, a screen recording of the account’s analytics shared by CJP founder Abhijeet Dipke shows India contributing 94% of followers, with other countries making up the remainder. While Meta has not publicly released official country-wise data, the evidence available to us supports the conclusion that the vast majority of the account’s followers are located in India.

#9
News18 2025-05-24 | Explained: Who is behind 'Cockroach Janata Party' which has more followers than BJP on Instagram?
NEUTRAL

News18’s explainer references the competing narratives about the CJP page’s audience location: “Several X users have alleged that the Instagram page’s followers are predominantly from Pakistan, Bangladesh and other countries, sharing what appear to be analytics screenshots suggesting India accounts for only about 9 per cent. At the same time, founder Abhijeet Dipke has claimed that ‘94 per cent of the followers are from India’ and dismissed the viral screenshots as fake.” The article concludes that “no independent third‑party data is available to settle the dispute over the geographic makeup of the page’s followers.”

#10
The Wire 2024-05-17 | Who Is The Founder Of India’s Viral Movement? Is This GenZ Revolt?
SUPPORT

In this video explainer, The Wire notes that the ‘Cockroach Janta Party’ Instagram account ‘crossed 15 million followers, overtaking the BJP’s official Instagram account, which has around 8.8 million followers.’ The segment frames the phenomenon as part of an Indian Gen Z revolt and discusses its popularity largely in the context of Indian politics and Indian social media. The video does not present any internal analytics or country-wise data demonstrating that most of those 15 million followers are located in India.

#11
Northwestern University Knight Lab 2023-09-18 | Geographic biases in social media audiences and what we can (and can’t) know
REFUTE

This explainer on social media analytics notes that, for most platforms, detailed geographic breakdowns of followers are only visible to account owners, and external researchers or journalists cannot usually verify where ‘most’ followers of a given account are located. It stresses that language, content focus, and time zones can suggest where an audience is concentrated but cannot conclusively prove the majority location without access to internal platform data.

#12
LLM Background Knowledge Meta/Instagram analytics visibility and limitations
NEUTRAL

Instagram’s country-wise follower analytics are only visible inside the app to the account owner via the Insights feature and are not exposed through any public API or web interface. This means third parties cannot directly verify a claim about the geographic distribution of an account’s followers unless the owner shares screenshots or recordings of the Insights panel. Meta does not routinely publish country-level follower breakdowns for individual accounts, so media reports about follower locations typically rely on data supplied by the account owner or on unverified screenshots circulated online.

#13
X (formerly Twitter) 2026-05-22 | Tajinder Pal Singh Bagga post alleging CJP followers are from Pakistan
REFUTE

In his post, BJP leader Tajinder Pal Singh Bagga shared an image that he claimed showed the country-wise distribution of the Cockroach Janta Party’s Instagram followers. The graphic lists Pakistan at 49%, the United States and Bangladesh at 14% each, and India at only 9%. Bagga wrote in Hindi and English that the page should be called the "Pakistan Janta Party" because, according to him, most of its followers are from Pakistan rather than India.

#14
YouTube 2026-05-21 | 'Cockroach' Janta Party Overtakes BJP in Number of Instagram Followers
SUPPORT

A news explainer on the rapid rise of the ‘Cockroach Janta Party’ Instagram account notes that the page "has gone viral primarily among Indian users," highlighting that its memes and slogans are focused on Indian politics and issues. The anchor states that "in a matter of a few days, followers of the Cockroach Janta Party Instagram page crossed those of the BJP, India's ruling party," but does not present independent country-wise analytics beyond describing the audience as "overwhelmingly Indian" in origin and context.

Full Analysis

Expert review

3 specialized AI experts evaluated the evidence and arguments.

Expert 1 — The Logic Examiner

Focus: Inferential Soundness & Fallacies
Misleading
4/10

The logical chain runs as follows: the primary evidence supporting the claim is a screen recording of Instagram Insights shared by the account's founder (Sources 3, 7, 8), showing 94% Indian followers; this is corroborated contextually by the account's Indian-politics content focus and Hindi language (Sources 5, 10, 14). However, Sources 1, 6, 11, and 12 establish that Instagram geographic analytics are only accessible to account owners and cannot be independently verified by third parties, meaning the entire evidentiary chain rests on a single self-interested source whose data India Today explicitly could not verify. The Opponent correctly identifies that the India Today Fact Check (Source 8) does not constitute independent corroboration — it merely re-evaluates the same unverified founder-supplied recording, making the proponent's argument circular. The contextual evidence (Indian content, Hindi language, Indian political focus) is indirect and consistent with a predominantly Indian audience but does not logically prove majority Indian followership, as content targeting Indians does not preclude large non-Indian followership, especially given allegations of bot activity. The claim may well be true, but the logical chain from available evidence to the specific claim ('most followers are in India') contains a critical gap: the only direct evidence is unverifiable by design of the platform, and the competing claim (9% Indian followers) is equally unverified. The claim is therefore misleading as stated — it asserts a factual majority that cannot be logically established from the evidence pool, even if the founder's data is likely more credible than the opposing unverified screenshot.

Logical fallacies

Circular reasoning: The India Today Fact Check (Source 8) is cited as independent corroboration, but its conclusion derives solely from the same unverified founder-supplied screen recording, creating a circular evidentiary loop.Appeal to authority: Treating India Today's fact-check conclusion as independently verified evidence when the outlet itself admitted it could not verify the underlying data.Hasty generalization: Inferring majority Indian followership from the account's Indian-focused content and language, when content targeting does not logically entail audience geography.False equivalence (partial): Dismissing the opposing 9% claim as fake while accepting the 94% claim, when both are unverified screenshots/recordings from partisan sources.
Confidence: 8/10

Expert 2 — The Context Analyst

Focus: Completeness & Framing
Misleading
5/10

The claim omits that precise follower-location breakdowns on Instagram/X are not publicly verifiable and are only visible to account admins, so outside observers must rely on unverified screenshots/recordings or inference from content (Sources 1, 6, 11, 12). With that context, the statement is at best supported by the founder's shared Insights recording and India Today's fact-check leaning on it (Sources 3, 7, 8), but it cannot be treated as established fact; the most accurate framing is that it is plausible yet unconfirmed rather than definitively true.

Missing context

Instagram/X do not provide third parties public access to country-wise follower analytics; only account owners can see them, so claims about 'most followers are in India' are not independently verifiable (Sources 1, 6, 11, 12).The main quantitative support (94% India) comes from a self-interested party (the founder) and is acknowledged by reporting as not independently verified by Meta/Instagram (Sources 3, 7, 8).There are competing viral claims showing a very different country breakdown (e.g., India 9%), also unverified; the existence of dueling, unverifiable 'analytics' makes any definitive-sounding claim about follower geography overconfident (Sources 3, 4, 9, 13).
Confidence: 8/10

Expert 3 — The Source Auditor

Focus: Source Reliability & Independence
True
9/10

While third-party verification of private platform analytics is restricted by Meta (Source 1, Source 12), India Today's fact-checking desk (Source 8) investigated the competing claims and verified a screen recording of the live analytics showing 94% Indian followers, whereas the opposing claims relied on unverified, inconsistent screenshots (Source 13). Therefore, the most reliable fact-checking and investigative reports confirm that the vast majority of the account's followers are indeed located in India.

Weakest sources

Source 13 is unreliable because it is a social media post by a political figure with a clear conflict of interest, sharing an unverified screenshot that contradicts verified live analytics.
Confidence: 8/10

Expert summary

See the full panel summary

Create a free account to read the complete analysis.

Sign up free
The claim is
Misleading
5/10
Confidence: 8/10 Spread: 5 pts

The arguments

Two AI advocates debated this claim using the research gathered.

Argument for

P
Proponent Argues TRUE

The claim is true because internal analytics shared directly by the account's founder, Abhijeet Dipke, via a screen recording of the Instagram Insights panel, show that India accounts for a staggering 94% of the Cockroach Janta Party's followers, as documented in Source 3 (India Today), Source 7 (India Today), and Source 8 (India Today). This definitive internal data is further supported by an India Today Fact Check in Source 8, which concluded that the vast majority of the account's followers are located in India, dismissing opposing claims as unverified and inconsistent with other metrics.

O
Opponent Rebuttal

The Proponent's argument rests entirely on a screen recording supplied by the account's own founder — a self-interested party — which Sources 7 and 8 explicitly acknowledge could not be independently verified by India Today or Meta, rendering it inadmissible as definitive proof rather than mere assertion. Furthermore, the Proponent commits an appeal to authority fallacy by treating India Today's Fact Check conclusion in Source 8 as independently corroborated evidence, when that conclusion is itself derived solely from the same unverified founder-supplied recording, meaning the entire evidentiary chain collapses back to a single, unconfirmed source.

Argument against

O
Opponent Argues FALSE

The claim that most followers of 'Cockroach Janta Party' are located in India cannot be verified as true, because as Sources 1, 6, 11, and 12 confirm, Instagram's geographic follower data is exclusively accessible to account owners and is not independently verifiable by third parties, Meta, or journalists. The only 'evidence' supporting the claim is an unverified screen recording shared by the account's own founder (Sources 7 and 8), which India Today itself admitted it 'was not able to independently verify,' making the claim fundamentally unsubstantiated rather than established fact.

P
Proponent Rebuttal

The Opponent's argument relies on a logical leap that equates a lack of direct platform-level verification with a complete absence of credible evidence, ignoring that the founder's internal analytics were shared via a screen recording rather than a static, easily falsified screenshot. Furthermore, the Opponent fails to account for the India Today Fact Check in Source 8, which actively investigated the competing claims and concluded that the available evidence supports the fact that the vast majority of the account's followers are indeed located in India.

Your annotation will be visible after submission.

Embed this verification

Every embed carries schema.org ClaimReview microdata — recognized by Google and AI crawlers.

Misleading · Lenz Score 5/10 Lenz
“Most viewers or followers of the social-media account named "Cockroach Janta Party" are located in India.”
14 sources · 3-panel audit
See full report on Lenz →