Verify any claim · lenz.io
“During the Russo-Ukrainian War, Russian forces held competitions to decapitate Ukrainian civilians and prisoners of war.”
The conclusion
Russian forces have been credibly implicated in beheadings, and a Rusich unit separately offered rewards for photographs of killed prisoners. However, the available evidence does not connect that contest to decapitation, establish multiple competitions, or show civilians were contest targets. The claim materially fuses separate atrocities into a more specific allegation that has not been substantiated.
Caveats
- Documented beheading incidents do not establish that beheading was the object of a competition.
- Only one relevant Rusich contest is identified, making the plural “competitions” unsupported.
- The evidence does not show that civilians were targets of the reported contest.
Fact-check inside the tools you already use
Connect Lenz to ChatGPT, Claude, or WhatsApp and check a claim mid-conversation.
Or create a free account to bookmark this verification and run your own checks.
Sources
Sources used in the analysis
The image, shared by the Russian Rusich unit on its Telegram channel, is accompanied by an announcement for a contest: “The first three people to submit a photo of prisoners who have clearly been erased from existence will receive a cryptocurrency reward.”
In addition, in June and August 2024, photos and a video that circulated on social media, including in channels with members who express support for the Russian armed forces, appear to show three dismembered or beheaded Ukrainian servicemen in separate incidents. … The photos and video raise serious concerns that the servicemen were executed, and/or their corpses desecrated after death, both of which are grave violations under IHL.
In the second video, a Russian serviceman beheaded a Ukrainian serviceman. OHCHR has reasonable grounds to believe that both videos, which were likely recorded before the reporting period, are authentic.
Since the end of August 2024, OHCHR has recorded a significant increase in credible allegations of executions of Ukrainian servicepersons captured by Russian armed forces, involving at least 62 individuals in 19 incidents.
The Human Rights Council on Wednesday heard gruesome testimony of torture, rape and execution of Ukrainian detainees and soldiers allegedly committed by Russian forces, as a high-level independent probe into Russia’s full-scale invasion delivered its latest mandated report in Geneva.
Ukrainian prosecutors are investigating reports of beheadings and a sword being used to kill a Ukrainian soldier with his hands tied behind his back.
In relation to the treatment of POWs in the power of the Russian Federation, OHCHR documented gross violations of IHRL, and serious violations of IHL that may constitute war crimes upon capture and immediately thereafter. They include the summary executions of 15 POWs, the use of POWs as human shields, the deaths of two wounded men POWs due to a lack of medical care, and torture or other ill-treatment to extract information.
UN reporting has documented widespread violations involving Ukrainian POWs and civilian detainees held by Russian authorities, including torture and ill-treatment, conflict-related sexual violence (CRSV), arbitrary detention, enforced disappearance, and executions.
On Tuesday, April 11, a video of the murder of what is likely a Ukrainian soldier by a Russian fighter began to spread on Russian and Ukrainian Telegram channels. The extremely brutal footage captures the decapitation of a still-living prisoner.
After the distribution of a video of the alleged decapitation of Ukrainian prisoners of war by Russians, representatives of the UN and the EU insist that those responsible for the executions must be held accountable. ... "A video is circulating in which Russians decapitate a Ukrainian soldier... And yet we are literally talking about the need for dialogue and competing with each other at the Olympics? What are we doing here?" he wrote on Twitter, adding that Estonia will support Ukraine until victory.
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky on Wednesday condemned as “beasts” those who purportedly beheaded Ukrainian soldiers shown in two videos that emerged on social media in the past week. … On Monday, the Institute for the Study of War (ISW) said that Wagner was “reportedly continuing to commit war crimes by beheading Ukrainian servicemen in Bakhmut,” referencing a photo shared on pro-Russian social media sites showing what appeared to be a severed head, which they claimed belonged to a Ukrainian soldier, mounted on a spike.
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy has called on world leaders to react after a video emerged online allegedly showing Russian soldiers beheading a Ukrainian captive with a knife. … "Yesterday, a video appeared on the Internet showing how the Russian occupiers are showing their beastly nature — cruelly torturing a Ukrainian prisoner and cutting off his head," the SBU agency wrote on Telegram.
Ukrainian investigators also report cases of extremely brutal killings, including decapitations, images of which have spread on Russian social media.
Ukrainian investigators have also alleged cases of extremely brutal murders, including beheadings, images of which have circulated on Russian social media.
In a post on social media, Kostin said his office had received information that Russian commanders had given orders "not to capture Ukrainian servicemen, but instead to kill them with inhuman cruelty - by beheading."
A new video of a brutal murder is circulating on the internet. In it, as the SBU claims, Russian military personnel cut off the head of a Ukrainian prisoner of war
Ukraine’s president Volodymyr Zelensky has urged world leaders to act after the emergence of footage appearing to show Russian soldiers beheading a Ukrainian prisoner of war.
Ukrainian Human Rights Commissioner Dmytro Lubinets appealed to the United Nations and the Red Cross on Friday over a video posted by several pro-Russian Telegram channels in which the decapitated head of a Ukrainian soldier is displayed on a pole. … Ukrainian newspaper Ukrainska Pravda wrote on Friday that it had obtained “intercepted audio recordings” from sources within the Armed Forces of Ukraine (AFU) indicating that a Russian serviceman “was ordered to cut off the heads of four dead Ukrainian soldiers”.
On February 2, Russian resources on the internet began distributing a photo of a Ukrainian serviceman with a severed head on a vessel.
The Security Service of Ukraine said the video showed “Russian occupiers … severely torturing a Ukrainian prisoner and cutting off his head.”
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky has called on world leaders to respond after a video emerged apparently showing a Ukrainian soldier being beheaded by a Russian serviceman.
A video was published in the closed Telegram channel of Vladislav Pozdnyakov, the creator of "Male State", showing a Ukrainian serviceman being beheaded.
Russian war criminals from the sabotage-assault reconnaissance group "Rusich" called on their "colleague" occupiers to kill captured Ukrainian defenders. The neo-Nazis even announced a cynical "contest" with a reward. The terrorists, known for their brutal violations of the laws and customs of war, asked on social media to send them photos of executed soldiers of the Defense Forces. Supposedly, the first three pictures will win the "contest".
Intercepted Russian radio chatter obtained by CNN appears to correspond with drone footage showing the suspected execution of Ukrainian prisoners of war last year.
Russian forces are summarily killing surrendering Ukrainian soldiers in increasing numbers on the battlefield, often shooting them point blank just after they have been taken prisoner, Ukrainian officials say.
Russian commanders gave the order not to take Ukrainian servicemen prisoner, but instead to decapitate them. On June 17, the Ukrainian military received information that servicemen of one of the Russian units in the Volnovakha district of Donetsk region ordered their subordinates not to capture servicemen of the Armed Forces of Ukraine and to cut off their heads.
Ukrainian Parliament's Commissioner for Human Rights Dmytro Lubinets said that 375 Ukrainian prisoners of war (POWs) and civilian hostages have died while in Russian captivity. … In addition, Lubinets reported at least 345 known cases of killings and executions by the occupiers of Ukrainian soldiers who had surrendered.
According to the latest data published by the Ukraine's Prosecutor-General's Office, investigators have so far obtained information on the execution of 93 Ukrainian prisoners of war by the Russian military, 80 percent of which were recorded this year.
A video depicting the decapitation of a Ukrainian prisoner of war by Russian soldiers was first published online on 11 April 2023, and then circulated through pro-Russian sources.
Ukraine launched an investigation Wednesday into a gruesome video that purportedly shows the beheading of a Ukrainian soldier, in the latest accusation of atrocities said to hav
The Russians have beheaded a Ukrainian soldier in Donetsk oblast, with Ukraine’s Prosecutor General reporting that this may be part of a Russian directive to not take Ukrainian prisoners of war, but instead use maximum savagery in killing them.
In April 2023, two separate videos were posted which appeared to show Russians beheading Ukrainian soldiers. One, posted on 8 April on a pro-Russian social media platform, showed the beheaded bodies of two Ukrainian soldiers. The other was posted on 11 April but may have been taken earlier. On it a Russian can be seen beheading a Ukrainian prisoner of war.
Major General Roman Demurchiev, deputy commander of Russia's 20th Combined Arms Army, regularly told relatives and colleagues about the murder and torture of Ukrainian prisoners—both military and civilian, according to an archive of his personal correspondence for 2022–2024 obtained by Schemes and System.
Note that on August 16, a video appeared on a Russian Telegram channel in which a Russian boasted of decapitating a Ukrainian. The Russian soldier showed a figure on the ground and a head impaled on a stick.
A video released on social networks, in which Russian mercenaries probably cut off the head of a living man in a Ukrainian military uniform and with identification marks characteristic of the Armed Forces of Ukraine (AFU) with a knife, caused resonance in the world.
In the video, people in military uniforms with Russian military insignia and wearing masks cut off the head of a living person in a uniform with Ukrainian insignia.
In some units, according to radio intercepts, Russian commanders practice involving their soldiers in executions, including with demonstrative brutality, to bind the "team" with blood and crimes so that the soldiers will fight to the last and not surrender to the Ukrainians,” “Karay” said.
Continue your research
Verify a related claim next.
Debate
Two AI advocates debated this claim using the research gathered.
Argument for
EL PAÍS (Source 1) directly documents the Russian Rusich unit publicly offering cryptocurrency prizes to the first three entrants who submitted photographs of prisoners “clearly ... erased from existence,” establishing an organized competition incentivizing the killing of captives. This competition sits within a documented Russian pattern of decapitation and execution: OHCHR found reasonable grounds that a Russian serviceman beheaded a Ukrainian serviceman (Source 3), while UN reporting documents executions of Ukrainian POWs and civilian detainees by Russian authorities (Source 8), substantiating the claim's characterization of the victims and method.
The Proponent's own citation of Source 1 confirms the Opening Argument's core distinction: Rusich's contest rewarded submitting photos of prisoners already 'erased from existence,' which is a trophy-hunting scheme for documenting killings, not a competition whose object was performing decapitation itself as the claim asserts. Stitching this photo-reward scheme together with separate, unrelated beheading incidents from Sources 3 and 8 is a textbook fallacy of composition, manufacturing a single organized 'decapitation competition' narrative that no individual source in the brief actually documents.'
Argument against
Every source in this brief documents beheadings, executions, and even a Rusich 'contest' for photos of already-killed Ukrainian prisoners (Sources 1, 23) — but none establish that Russian forces held a live 'competition to decapitate' people, i.e., a contest whose object was the act of beheading itself rather than a grim reward for submitting images of corpses. This is a critical distinction: the OHCHR, BBC, CNN, and Wikipedia sources (2, 3, 6, 9, 11, 29) describe isolated, gruesome killings and social-media boasting, not a documented organized 'decapitation competition,' meaning the claim as stated conflates two separate, unverified narratives into a more sensationalized and unsubstantiated atrocity than the actual evidence supports.
The Opponent imposes a straw-man requirement that the contest's rules expressly name decapitation, although Source 1 documents Rusich offering cryptocurrency prizes for photographs of prisoners “erased from existence,” which is direct evidence of an organized competition incentivizing their killing. Treating the contest and decapitations as unrelated ignores corroborative context: OHCHR found reasonable grounds that a Russian serviceman beheaded a Ukrainian serviceman (Source 3) and recorded credible evidence of beheaded Ukrainian servicemen (Source 2), supporting the claim's characterization rather than refuting it.
Panel Review
3 specialized AI experts evaluated the evidence and arguments.
Reviewer 1 — The Logic Examiner
Source 1 directly supports a Rusich contest rewarding photos of prisoners who had been killed, while Sources 2–3 document or credibly indicate separate beheading incidents; none links the contest to decapitation or establishes that civilians were contest targets. The claim therefore combines distinct facts into an unsupported allegation of competitions to decapitate Ukrainian civilians and POWs, so it is false as worded.
Reviewer 2 — The Source Auditor
The most reliable sources—OHCHR periodic reports (Sources 2, 3, 4) and major outlets like El País (Source 1), BBC, and AP—confirm Russian forces carried out beheadings and summary executions of Ukrainian POWs (and some related desecration), plus a Rusich unit photo contest offering crypto for images of prisoners already “erased from existence.” None of these independent, high-quality sources document organized competitions whose object was the act of decapitating Ukrainian civilians or POWs, so the claim as worded is not supported.
Reviewer 3 — The Precision Analyst
The claim asserts a specific, organized 'competition to decapitate' civilians and POWs, but the evidence (Sources 1, 23) documents a Rusich unit contest rewarding photos of already-killed/'erased' prisoners with cryptocurrency, not a contest whose object was performing beheadings; separately, Sources 2, 3, 6, 9, 12, 15, 18, 26, 29 document numerous discrete beheading incidents and even alleged orders to decapitate rather than capture, but no source ties any prize competition specifically to decapitation as the winning act, and no source shows civilians (as opposed to POWs/soldiers) being targeted by any such contest. The claim fuses two real but distinct atrocity patterns—a photo/kill-count contest and multiple beheading incidents—into a single fabricated causal/organizational structure ('competitions to decapitate') that overstates precision on both the causal link (contest→decapitation) and the scope ('civilians'), making it Mostly False as worded despite a true underlying kernel of extreme brutality.
Panel summary
Reliable UN reporting and major news organizations document Russian forces beheading or executing Ukrainian POWs. Separate reporting describes one Rusich unit contest that offered cryptocurrency for photographs of prisoners who had been killed. No credible source establishes that this contest rewarded decapitation, that multiple such competitions occurred, or that civilians were included as targets. The claim therefore combines two documented but distinct atrocity patterns into an unsupported allegation. Because real beheadings and a real prisoner-related contest provide a factual kernel, the evidence supports Mostly False rather than False.