Skip to content

Claim analyzed

General

“Startup founders who demonstrate a strong ability to conceal their emotions and intentions (a good “poker face”) are more likely to build unicorn companies (startups valued at $1 billion or more) than founders who do not.”

The conclusion

Mixed
5/10

The evidence does not establish that founders with a strong poker face are more likely to build unicorn companies. One study links emotion suppression to two-year venture survival, but other findings associate suppression with weaker leadership emergence and team relationships, while smiling improves investor responses. These are mixed findings about early venture outcomes; none of the studies compares founders' concealment abilities with their likelihood of reaching a $1 billion valuation.

Caveats

  • Limited source coverage. Low confidence conclusion.
  • Two-year survival, investor responses and leadership emergence do not establish the likelihood of reaching a $1 billion valuation.
  • Emotion suppression and smiling are not equivalent to skill at concealing both emotions and intentions.
  • The survival finding rests on a follow-up sample of 35 teams and one-tailed statistical tests, limiting broader conclusions.

Sources

Ranked by source quality and relevance

#1
nature.com 2025-07-31 | Founder smiles increase investor trust and funding | Scientific Reports

Finally, in a randomized experiment with 51 venture capitalists, founders were assessed as having a 16.6% higher probability of a successful exit and were valued $2.1 million more than non-smiling founders, with trustworthiness mediating 36% and 27% of the overall treatment effect for venture valuation and exit probability, respectively. … The practical implications of our research is obvious; entrepreneurs seeking external funding should smile for their profile pictures and when they pitch. Smiling conveys trustworthiness. … In conclusion, our research provides robust evidence that entrepreneurs’ smiles cause investors to invest by making entrepreneurs appear more trustworthy.… A study of 1,091 Shark Tank pitches further reveals that smiling is associated with higher funding odds, with trustworthiness serving as a key mediator. Finally, in a randomized experiment with 51 venture capitalists, founders were assessed as having a 16.6% higher probability of a successful exit and were valued $2.1 million more than non-smiling founders, with trustworthiness mediating 36% and 27% of the overall treatment effect for venture valuation and exit probability, respectively. Introduction … ### Practical implications The practical implications of our research is obvious; entrepreneurs seeking external funding should smile for their profile pictures and when they pitch. Smiling conveys trustworthiness. Limitations and future directions … ## Conclusion In conclusion, our research provides robust evidence that entrepreneurs’ smiles cause investors to invest by making entrepreneurs appear more trustworthy. Through two pilot studies and three main studies, we demonstrate that smiling is more than just a social cue; it plays a pivotal role in early-stage investment decisions. Our findings extend prior observational research by establishing causality and identifying trustworthiness as a key mediating factor. …

#2
doi.org 2020-02-03 | Leader Emergence in Nascent Venture Teams: The Critical Roles of Individual Emotion Regulation and Team Emotions

Data from 103 nascent venture teams without prior leaders show a negative relationship between individuals’ trait disposition to suppress emo tions and their emergence as leaders, and a positive relationship between their trait disposition to reappraise emotions and their emergence as leaders. … The results of Model 2 confirm that the relationship between sup pression and leader emergence is negative and significant (β = –0.07, p < 0.05). … In a sample of nascent venture teams without existing leaders, we found that while the reap praisal aspect of emotion regulation helps individuals establish themselves as leaders, the suppression aspect hinders leader emergence.… We also theorize that team emotions arising from affective events moderate the relationship between reappraisal and leader emergence in such teams. Data from 103 nascent venture teams without prior leaders show a negative relationship between individuals’ trait disposition to suppress emo tions and their emergence as leaders, and a positive relationship between their trait disposition to reappraise emotions and their emergence as leaders. Moreover, we find that negative team emotions magnify the positive association between reappraisal and leader emergence, while positive team emotions mitigate it. We discuss the implications of our findings for the literature on entrepre neurial leadership, entrepreneurial emotions, and leadership in general. … Hypothesis 2 suggests that in a nascent venture team, an individual with stronger tendency to suppress emotions is less likely to emerge as a leader, than an individual with weaker tendency to suppress emotions. The results of Model 2 confirm that the relationship between sup pression and leader emergence is negative and significant (β = –0.07, p < 0.05). Model 3 evaluates Hypothesis 3a, which proposes that positive emotions within a na scent venture team mitigate the positive relationship between reappraisal and leader emergence. Model 3 confirms that positive team emotions negatively moderate the re lationship between reappraisal and leader emergence (β = –0.10, p < 0.05). … This multilevel perspective explains not only the link between individuals’ emotion regulation and their emergence as leaders in teams, but also stipulates how the strength of this link decreases or increases given different levels of positive and negative emotions in the team. In a sample of nascent venture teams without existing leaders, we found that while the reap praisal aspect of emotion regulation helps individuals establish themselves as leaders, the suppression aspect hinders leader emergence. Moreover, our data suggest that the effects of individual entrepreneurs’ reappraisals depend on the emotions of their teams: positive team emotions mitigate the positive effect, whereas negative team emotions magnify it. Leader Emergence in Nascent Venture Teams 955 © 2020 The Authors. …

#3
journals.sagepub.com 2023-01-01 | Holding Back or Letting Go? The Effect of Emotion Suppression on Relationship Viability in New Venture Teams - Stela Ivanova, Theresa Treffers, Fred Langerak, Markus Groth, 2023

A follow-up study after two years indicates that relationship viability and emotion suppression significantly predict venture survival. … Furthermore, we found a positive effect of suppression on venture survival, and this effect was significant at the 0.05 level. This result indicates that ventures in which individual members were more likely to suppress their emotional expressions were more than eight times more likely to survive two years later (β = 2.12; Exp(B) = 8.33; p < .05, one-tailed).… A round-robin study with 93 respondents nested in 37 NVTs, which generated 167 observations, provides empirical support for the theoretically derived model by showing that both authenticity and appropriateness fully mediate the relationship between emotion suppression and relationship viability. In particular, the findings show that the negative indirect effect of emotion suppression on relationship viability via authenticity is larger than the positive indirect effect via appropriateness. A follow-up study after two years indicates that relationship viability and emotion suppression significantly predict venture survival. Together, these findings make ample contributions to the literature and provide interesting opportunities for further research. JEL: L26, M13, C92. … Notes. N = 35, * p < .05, ** p < .01. AIC = Akaike information criterion. Models with lower values of AIC are preferred. BIC = Bayesian information criterion. Models with lower values of BIC are preferred. All coefficients are reported in log-odds. One-tailed significance tests reported. Furthermore, we found a positive effect of suppression on venture survival, and this effect was significant at the 0.05 level. This result indicates that ventures in which individual members were more likely to suppress their emotional expressions were more than eight times more likely to survive two years later (β = 2.12; Exp(B) = 8.33; p < .05, one-tailed). Overall, our results from the follow-up study suggest that both relationship viability and emotion suppression play a key role in predicting venture survival, supporting the overall predictive validity of our initial findings. Discussion

Debate

Two AI advocates debated this claim using the research gathered.

Argument for

P
Proponent Argues TRUE

Source 3 (SAGE) finds that venture members who suppress emotional expressions were more than eight times as likely to lead ventures surviving two years, establishing that poker-face-like emotional concealment is a powerful predictor of the durability required to reach unicorn scale. Source 1 (Scientific Reports) further shows that strategically managed visible affect changes investor trust, funding, valuation, and perceived exit prospects, so founders able to control what they reveal possess a concrete financing advantage that makes unicorn outcomes more likely.

O
Opponent Rebuttal

The Proponent commits a massive non sequitur by conflating basic two-year survival in a small sample of 35 nascent teams (Source 3, journals.sagepub.com) with achieving a $1 billion unicorn valuation, while ignoring that the exact same study proves emotional suppression degrades team authenticity and relationship viability, and that Source 2 (doi.org) shows it actively prevents individuals from emerging as venture leaders. Furthermore, the Proponent blatantly misrepresents Source 1 (nature.com) by framing overt emotional expression—specifically smiling—as "emotional concealment," when the study actually proves that non-smiling founders who maintain a neutral "poker face" suffer from lower investor trust, reduced funding odds, and valuations $2.1 million lower than expressive founders.

Argument against

O
Opponent Argues FALSE

There is zero empirical evidence in the research brief linking emotional concealment or a "poker face" to building a $1 billion unicorn company, as even the study associating emotional suppression with early two-year survival Simultaneously found that it damages team authenticity and relationship viability (Source 3, journals.sagepub.com). On the contrary, scientific research demonstrates that suppressing emotions actually hinders a founder's ability to emerge as a venture leader (Source 2, doi.org), whereas openly expressing positive emotion by smiling increases investor trust, boosts funding odds, and yields higher company valuations and exit probabilities than maintaining a non-smiling poker face (Source 1, nature.com).

P
Proponent Rebuttal

The Opponent commits a false dichotomy by treating a smile as the opposite of a poker face: Source 1 shows that strategically displaying a trust-building emotion improves funding, valuation, and exit expectations, which is consistent with—rather than contrary to—the value of controlling what one reveals. The Opponent also overstates Source 2, which concerns leader emergence in nascent teams, while Source 3 directly finds that emotion suppression significantly predicts two-year venture survival; neither study measures unicorn formation, but survival and financing are materially relevant pathways to it.

Panel Review

5 reviewers assessed the evidence and the arguments.

Reviewer A · Claude

Mostly False
3/10

No source measures unicorn formation or a founder's poker-face ability. Source 3 links emotion suppression to two-year venture survival, but that finding comes from a small sample and the same study finds suppression harms authenticity and relationship viability. Source 2 finds suppression is negatively associated with leader emergence in nascent teams. Source 1 shows smiling raises trust and funding, which does not support concealment as an advantage and arguably points the other way. Survival over two years is not unicorn status, and the evidence is mixed and indirect at best. The claim's central assertion is unsupported, and some evidence runs against it, so it leans Mostly False rather than no-record.

Source issues

  • Source 3 rests on a very small sample of 35 teams at follow-up and uses one-tailed tests.
  • Source 1 concerns smiling and trust, not concealment of emotions or intentions.

Evidence gaps

  • No source measures founders' poker-face ability against unicorn outcomes.
  • No source tracks founders through to a $1 billion valuation.
  • Emotion suppression as measured in the studies is not the same construct as concealing intentions.

Precision issues

  • The claim asserts a comparative likelihood of building unicorns, but the evidence covers only survival, leader emergence or funding.
  • Suppression of emotional expression is treated as equivalent to a strategic poker face, which the studies do not establish.

Reviewer B · GPT

No Public Record

Source 3 reports that greater emotion suppression among members of new venture teams predicted two-year venture survival, but it does not study founders specifically or unicorn valuations. Source 2 directly finds that emotion suppression negatively predicted leader emergence in 103 nascent venture teams, while Source 1 finds that smiling increased investor trust, funding odds, valuation, and perceived exit prospects; neither source measures building a $1 billion company. These reliable academic sources therefore provide mixed, indirect evidence about early venture outcomes rather than direct evidence that founders with a good poker face are more likely to build unicorns. The claim's central unicorn-outcome assertion is not recorded in the evidence, so the verdict is Mixed.

Source issues

  • Source 3's follow-up evidence concerns a small set of nascent venture teams and reports a two-year survival outcome rather than a unicorn outcome.
  • Source 1's experimental outcomes are investor assessments, funding-related measures, and perceived exit probability, not observed unicorn formation.

Evidence gaps

  • No source measures whether founders who conceal emotions and intentions are more likely to build startups valued at $1 billion or more.
  • Sources 2 and 3 measure emotion suppression in nascent venture-team members, not founders' ability to conceal both emotions and intentions.
  • Source 1 measures smiling versus non-smiling behavior, not a good poker face or concealment of intentions.

Precision issues

  • The claim treats a good poker face as concealment of both emotions and intentions, but the cited studies address emotional suppression or smiling and do not measure concealment of intentions.

Reviewer C · Gemini

No Public Record

The provided peer-reviewed studies investigate emotional suppression, leader emergence, early venture survival, and smiling in investor pitches, but none measure or evaluate the likelihood of building unicorn companies valued at $1 billion or more (Sources 1, 2, 3). In fact, Source 1 shows that expressing positive emotions like smiling significantly increases investor trust, venture valuation, and exit probabilities compared to non-smiling faces, while Source 2 demonstrates that suppressing emotions negatively impacts leader emergence. With the central empirical relationship between a 'poker face' and unicorn status lacking any empirical backing in the literature, the specific claim is unrecorded and unsupported.

Evidence gaps

  • No source investigates or tracks unicorn outcomes ($1 billion+ valuation) in relation to emotional concealment or a poker face.
  • Source 3 examines two-year new venture survival in a small sample, not unicorn scaling.
  • Source 1 examines smiling rather than concealing emotions, and finds non-smiling founders receive lower valuations.

Precision issues

  • The claim asserts a specific comparative outcome regarding unicorn companies ($1B+ valuation) that is not supported by the cited literature.

Reviewer D · Grok

Mostly False
3/10

Sources 1 and 2 directly find disadvantages to non-smiling and emotion suppression: smiling raises investor trust, funding, valuation, and perceived exit probability, while suppression reduces leader emergence in nascent venture teams. Source 3 finds that suppression predicts two-year survival but also harms authenticity and relationship viability, and none of the studies measures unicorn formation. The claim therefore asserts a stronger and different outcome than the evidence supports, while the most relevant findings point against concealment being advantageous. The claim is mostly false.

Source issues

  • Sources 1, 2, and 3 are peer-reviewed academic studies, but all concern early-stage teams, funding cues, or short-term survival rather than unicorn outcomes.

Evidence gaps

  • No source measures unicorn valuations or compares founders who conceal emotions and intentions with those who do not on the probability of reaching a $1 billion valuation.

Precision issues

  • The claim treats two-year venture survival and early funding cues as evidence of a higher likelihood of building a unicorn, which is a much stronger and different outcome.
  • A poker face is equated with emotion suppression and with not smiling, although the studies measure distinct behaviors and do not assess concealment of intentions.

Reviewer E · GPT

No Public Record

The peer-reviewed studies address smiling and investor responses (Source 1), emotion suppression and leader emergence (Source 2), and suppression, team relationships, and two-year venture survival (Source 3). None measures whether founders skilled at concealing emotions and intentions are more likely to build companies valued at $1 billion or more. The proponent extrapolates from survival and financing to unicorn outcomes, while the opponent treats findings about different outcomes as direct refutations; neither inference establishes the claimed relationship. Because the central association is not recorded in the supplied evidence, the verdict is Mixed under the no-public-record rule, rather than False.

Source issues

  • Source 3's venture-survival follow-up reports only 35 observations and uses one-tailed significance tests, limiting the strength of broader extrapolation.

Evidence gaps

  • No source compares unicorn formation rates between founders with strong and weak abilities to conceal emotions and intentions.
  • Emotion-suppression tendencies and displayed smiles do not directly measure skill at concealing both emotions and intentions.
  • Investor assessments, leader emergence, and two-year survival are different outcomes from attaining a valuation of at least $1 billion.

Precision issues

  • The claim states a comparative likelihood of unicorn formation that the evidence does not establish.

Panel summary

The peer-reviewed sources provide credible but indirect evidence about emotional expression and early venture outcomes. One study associates emotion suppression with two-year venture survival, offering limited support for a possible advantage. Other findings associate suppression with weaker leader emergence and relationship viability, while smiling improves investor responses. The disagreement centers on whether these adverse findings contradict the claim or merely concern different outcomes. Because none measures unicorn formation or skill at concealing intentions, they cannot establish or refute the claimed comparative likelihood. The Mixed verdict reflects these divergent findings and the central evidence gap, rather than a demonstrated link to billion-dollar valuations.

See the full panel summary

Create a free account to read the complete analysis.

Sign up free
The claim is
Mixed
Score: 5/10
Confidence: 5/10 Spread: 2 pts

Only you will see this note.

Embed this verification

Every embed carries schema.org ClaimReview microdata — recognized by Google and AI crawlers.

Mixed · Lenz Score 5/10 Lenz
“Startup founders who demonstrate a strong ability to conceal their emotions and intentions (a good “poker face”) are more likely to build unicorn companies (startups valued at $1 billion or more) than founders who do not.”
3 sources · 5-panel audit · Verified Nov 2026
See full report on Lenz →