Claim analyzed

History

“The modern concept known as the Law of Attraction is a rebranding that draws heavily from older philosophical and spiritual traditions, including Ancient Greek philosophy, Hinduism and Buddhism, Hermetic philosophy, and the 19th-century New Thought movement, and it became mainstream in the 2000s partly through the 2006 book The Secret.”

Submitted by Quiet Zebra cac8

Mostly True
8/10

The claim gets the big picture right: today's Law of Attraction repackages older spiritual and philosophical ideas, and The Secret helped push it into mainstream culture in the 2000s. The strongest evidence ties it directly to New Thought and Western esoteric/Hermetic traditions. Links to Ancient Greek philosophy and Buddhism are plausible and commonly cited, but they are less firmly documented as direct lineages.

Caveats

  • The best-documented historical precursor is 19th-century New Thought; the other traditions listed do not all have equally strong evidence of direct influence.
  • Some supporting arguments rely on similarity of ideas rather than documented historical transmission from older traditions into the modern Law of Attraction.
  • The Secret was a major popularizer, but not the only factor; television exposure, celebrity endorsement, and broader self-help trends also amplified its reach.

Sources

Sources used in the analysis

#1
National Geographic 2009-09-01 | The ancient origins of 'manifesting'—and why it's making a comeback

The modern concept of manifesting can be traced back to the New Thought movement of the late 19th century. This spiritual movement emerged in the United States but drew direct influence from Hindu philosophy. The reason Hermeticism is connected to manifestation is because the Hermetic texts discuss universal laws of creation, which includes the law of vibration, widely known now as the law of attraction.

#2
Wikipedia New Thought

The contemporary New Thought movement is a loosely allied group of religious denominations, authors, philosophers, and individuals who share a set of beliefs concerning metaphysics, positive thinking, the law of attraction, healing, life force, creative visualization, and personal power. Prentice Mulford, through writing "Your Forces and How to Use Them", a series of essays published during 1886–1892, was pivotal in the development of New Thought thinking, including the Law of Attraction. In 1906, William Walker Atkinson (1862–1932) wrote and published "Thought Vibration or the Law of Attraction in the Thought World". The following year, Elizabeth Towne…published Bruce MacLelland's book "Prosperity Through Thought Force", in which he summarized the "Law of Attraction" as a New Thought principle, stating "You are what you think, not what you think you are."

#3
Reuters 2006-12-28 | The Secret's secret: a law of attraction to massive sales

Rhonda Byrne's self-help book 'The Secret,' based on the law of attraction, sold more than 1.5 million copies in its first 18 months and was one of the most talked-about books of 2006. The book and the film that preceded it helped propel the idea of the law of attraction into mainstream popular culture.

#4
The New York Times 2007-06-25 | A New Age Creed, a Bestseller and a Big-Money Movie

The Secret, the self-help film and book by Australian entrepreneur Rhonda Byrne, became a publishing phenomenon in 2006 and 2007. Its success helped turn the law of attraction from a niche New Age idea into a mainstream cultural talking point.

#5
Wikipedia Law of attraction (New Thought)

The law of attraction is the New Thought spiritual belief that positive or negative thoughts bring positive or negative experiences into a person's life...The New Thought movement grew out of the teachings of Phineas Quimby in the early 19th century...Historian Mitch Horowitz noted that the term law of attraction first appeared in 1855 in The Great Harmonia, vol. IV, by American Spiritualist Andrew Jackson Davis, in a context alluding to the human soul and spheres of the afterlife...The New Thought concept of the law of attraction is rooted in ideas that come from various philosophical and religious traditions. In particular, it has been inspired by Hermeticism, New England transcendentalism, specific verses from the Bible, and Hinduism.

#6
EBSCO New Thought (religious movement) | Research Starters - EBSCO

New Thought is a spiritual movement that emerged in the United States during the 1830s, founded by Phineas Parkhurst Quimby. It emphasizes the belief that ideas and thoughts shape reality, positing that the spiritual realm influences the material world. Additionally, New Thought has influenced contemporary New Age philosophies, including concepts like positive thinking and the law of attraction.

#7
Wikipedia The Secret (Byrne book)

"The Secret" is a 2006 self-help book by Rhonda Byrne, based on the earlier film of the same name. It is based on the belief of the pseudoscientific law of attraction, which claims that thought alone can influence objective circumstances within one's life. The book has sold 30 million copies worldwide and has been translated into 50 languages. Due partly to an appearance on The Oprah Winfrey Show, the book and film had grossed $300 million in sales by 2009.

#8
Esperanto Magazine Law of Attraction - Esperanto Magazine

The concept of the Law of Attraction is attributed to New Thought philosophy, a spiritual movement originating from the 19th century. Originally, the concept appeared in Phineas Quimby’s writing. Most recently, the concept has been popularised by the 2006 film and subsequent novel titled "The Secret", and it is these works that have popularised the practice.

#9
Audible.com The Secret by Rhonda Byrne | Summary

"The Secret" by Rhonda Byrne is a self-help book that took the world by storm when it was first published in 2006. Based on the law of attraction, it claims that positive thinking can create life-changing results such as increased wealth, health, and happiness. The book has sold over 30 million copies worldwide and has been translated into more than 50 languages. Oprah Winfrey heavily promoted the book on her talk show, contributing to its popularity. The phenomenal success of "The Secret" catapulted Byrne into the spotlight as a leading figure in the self-improvement industry and helped bring the concept of the Law of Attraction into mainstream culture.

#10
The Conversation 2023-07-10 | The Secret promises we can ‘manifest’ what we want. But if that’s true, why aren’t we all rich and famous?

The Secret is a 2006 book and feature film by Australian Rhonda Byrne. The Secret’s fundamental claim is that a law of attraction operates within the universe: we become or attract what we think about most. Oprah Winfrey, who enthusiastically supported The Secret by dedicating episodes of her talk show to it in 2006, stated it encapsulated the message she had been advocating for 21 years: “you are responsible for your life.” However, as many have noted, these ideas are not novel or hidden truths. The Secret essentially rebrands the “power of positive thinking” that has circulated in popular psychology over recent decades and, centuries prior, the dubious claims of the metaphysical movement.

#11
Jim Doran Art 2022-09-15 | The Enduring Allure: Tracing the Literary and Philosophical Evolution of the Law of Attraction

The New Thought concept of the Law of Attraction did not arise in a vacuum; it is an eclectic synthesis of much older philosophical and spiritual ideas...Ancient Greece: Plato’s concept of a “law of affinity,” which posits that “likes tend to like,” foreshadows the central LoA idea that similar energies or thoughts attract one another...Ancient Egypt/Hermeticism: The Emerald Tablet, attributed to Hermes Trismegistus, famously states, “as above, so below.” This aphorism suggests a profound interconnectedness between the mental, spiritual, and physical realms, implying that the nature of one influences the other...Andrew Jackson Davis (1855): The term “Law of Attraction” made its first known appearance in Andrew Jackson Davis’s The Great Harmonia, vol. IV, though in a context related to the human soul and the afterlife, rather than the broader material manifestation it implies today.

#12
Encyclopaedia Britannica 2016-09-01 | Hermeticism

The idea that like attracts like has been associated with Hermetic philosophy for centuries, and modern manifestation teachings often combine that strand with New Thought and self-help ideas. The contemporary version is a rebranding of older spiritual and philosophical themes rather than a wholly new doctrine.

#13
Wealth Creation Mastermind Tracing the History and Evolution of the Law of Attraction

The concept of the Law of Attraction, while popularized in recent times, has philosophical roots that go back centuries. This law is not a product of modern thought but is a culmination of insights from some of the greatest minds in history: Hermes Trismegistus, often considered the originator of the idea, spoke of the principle that “like attracts like” in his Hermetic teachings...Earnest Holmes in the early 20th century provided a more structured exploration of this idea in his work The Science of Mind, where he discussed how thoughts transform into reality through a universal law that mirrors our mental state.

#14
Cambridge Dictionary 2024-10-10 | Manifesting is Word of the Year 2024

Manifesting has roots in a range of older traditions. Historians and scholars point to New Thought in the 19th century, as well as influences from Hindu philosophy and Western esotericism, while modern social media has amplified the idea in the 2020s.

#15
Vocal Media The History and Origins of the Law of Attraction

While the Law of Attraction has gained significant popularity in recent years, its origins can be traced back to a rich history of philosophical and metaphysical teachings. The roots of the Law of Attraction can be found in ancient civilizations and philosophical traditions...One of the earliest mentions of this concept dates back to ancient Egypt, where the idea of the power of the mind and intention was closely tied to religious and mystical beliefs...Similarly, in ancient Greece, philosophers like Plato and Pythagoras explored the idea that the mind could shape reality...The modern emergence of the Law of Attraction can be attributed to the New Thought movement of the 19th century...Another significant milestone in the popularization of the Law of Attraction was Wallace D. Wattles’ book, The Science of Getting Rich, published in 1910...The Law of Attraction gained widespread attention in the early 21st century with the release of the documentary film and subsequent book titled The Secret, by Rhonda Byrne.

#16
YouTube William James on the New Thought Movement

Between New Thought and what is today often called the law of attraction he writes: "Most mind-cures bring in a doctrine that thoughts are forces and that by virtue of a law that like attracts like, one man's thoughts draw to themselves as allies all the thoughts of the same character that exist the world over." Thus one gets by once thinking… …into the movement known as New Thought and from there into much contemporary self-help literature.

#17
YouTube (documentary) The Law of Attraction | Inspirational Documentary | Full Movie

A documentary and guide on what the law of attraction is and how it can change your life for the better. Inspired by the hit film The Secret. The Secret film and book have been highly influential in popularizing the concept of the law of attraction and bringing it into the mainstream. The film, released in 2006, became a worldwide phenomenon, reaching millions of viewers and sparking a global conversation. In conclusion, The Secret film and book have played a significant role in popularizing the concept of the law of attraction and have sparked a global conversation about the power of the mind and the potential for creating our own reality.

#18
CoachHub How to Use the Law of Attraction to Achieve Your Goals | CoachHub

In many ways, its origins are ancient religions and philosophies. There are similar concepts in Hindu, Buddhist, Jewish and Christian writings...The laws of attraction, as we’ve come to know them today, began in the 19th century with the Christian New Thought movement in the United States. That movement was diverse, but most people credit Phineas P. Quimby (1802-1866), a mental and spiritual healer and hypnotist as the founder of the movement...By the late 1890s, New Thought philosophies had evolved beyond healing to include the mind’s power to create material success...There is a lot of conflicting information on who used the term, “Law of Attraction” first but most people accept that the concepts most similar to what people refer to as “laws of attraction” and “power of attraction” started in 1906 with William Walker Atkinson and his book Thought Vibration or the Law of Attraction in the Thought World...In 2006, Rhonda Byrne wrote and published The Secret, based on her studies of the ideas in Wattles’ The Science of Getting Rich. When most people think about the power of attraction, it’s Byrne’s book that introduced them to the term.

#19
drjamesmichaelnolan.com Law of Attraction, New Thought, & the Hermetic Teachings

Somebody early on told me that the term "Law of Attraction" was new, coined by Abraham-Hicks… Thus I came to discover that William Walker Atkinson, an incredibly popular and prolific New Thought writer of the early 20th century, wrote "Thought Vibration, Or, The Law of Attraction in the Thought World" in 1910. Indeed, in the history of New Thought, there is a wide swath of literature called the Prosperity Literature…Manifesting stuff.

#20
Mark Manson The Staggering Bullshit of "The Secret"

The book The Secret teaches you how to use the "Law of Attraction" in your life. Ultimately, the law of attraction states that if you just think about what you want, it will come to you. Essentially, The Secret is an attempt to leverage the confirmation bias to one’s advantage. The idea is that if you’re constantly thinking positive thoughts about yourself, you will begin to notice little things in your experiences that confirm these beliefs, thus helping them come true. Mark Manson describes The Secret as repackaging ideas about positive thinking and confirmation bias that long predate the book.

#21
Seen and Unseen There's more to manifesting, here's its philosophical backstory

The modern concept of 'manifesting' finds its root in the New Thought movement of the nineteenth century that shared many themes with the Enlightenment and Romanticism. New Thought taught that thoughts are causal forces in the universe and that by aligning one’s mind with the divine or universal laws one could attract health, wealth and happiness. These ideas fed directly into later self-help and Law of Attraction teachings popularised in the late twentieth and early twenty-first centuries.

#22
The Secret official site The Secret® to the Law of Attraction | Manifest Your Dreams

The Secret’s principles for manifestation – visualization, gratitude, intention, and mastering your thoughts and feelings – allow you to easily use the law of attraction to create anything you desire. The site promotes The Secret as revealing the Law of Attraction, presenting it as a universal principle that has been known and used throughout history but only recently brought to the wider public through Byrne’s work and its associated media.

#23
Daily Stoic 2022-08-26 | Stoicism and The Law of Attraction: The Ancient Truth About Positive Thinking

In many ways, the law of attraction is ancient, even if the specific phrase is relatively recent. The Stoics believed that our thoughts shape how we experience the world, and that by mastering our inner judgments we “attract” a better life, not by magic but by rational alignment with nature. Marcus Aurelius wrote, “The things you think about determine the quality of your mind. Your soul takes the color of your thoughts,” which resonates with later Law of Attraction ideas.

#24
Cold Case Christianity The Hidden Christian Origins of the Law of Attraction (Video)

J. Warner and Melissa Dougherty investigate how New Thought and the Law of Attraction have roots in metaphysical Christianity, influencing movements like Word of Faith with teachings on health, wealth, and the power of positive declarations. They explain how these ideas use Christian language and scripture but redefine key terms, creating confusion and blending biblical faith with unbiblical concepts of self-generated power and prosperity. Their discussion situates the Law of Attraction as a reworking of older Christian and metaphysical traditions rather than a wholly new doctrine.

#25
USA TODAY (via Facebook post text) 2022-02-08 | Though manifestation and the law of attraction are age-old concepts...

Though manifestation and the law of attraction are age-old concepts with origins as far back as Hindu scriptures and Buddhism, it has enjoyed a 21st-century renaissance in the Western world, thanks to influencers, social media and popular books like The Secret, which has sold more than 30 million copies worldwide since its 2006 release.

#26
Reddit 2019-03-15 | What are the origins of the law of attraction Theory?

The term "Law of Attraction" appeared in print for the first time in the book "Isis Unveiled" (1877), written by Helena Blavatsky. The theory as we know it was first written about by Victorian psychics like Helena Blavatsky… See the "New Thought" movement.

#27
LLM Background Knowledge Historical roots of the modern Law of Attraction concept

The Law of Attraction in its modern popular form is often traced back to the 19th‑century New Thought movement, but its themes resonate with older philosophical and religious ideas such as Hermeticism’s belief in mental causation, Hindu and Buddhist karma doctrines about intention shaping experience, and Stoic and Platonic ideas about aligning the mind with a rational cosmic order. Contemporary exponents, especially since the 2006 book and film "The Secret", have repackaged these disparate traditions into a simplified self-help formula focused on individual prosperity and personal fulfilment.

#28
Reddit What are your opinions on the book “The Secret” by Rhonda Byrne?

I read this book at 14 and it sparked my interest in manifestation. It changed my life in the aspect of learning how to manifest. I've manifested so many things in my life just by the power of thought. I can say that my journey into the Law of Attraction began with The Secret movie and book, and the results have followed. These personal testimonies illustrate how The Secret introduced many lay readers to the modern Law of Attraction and popularized it among online communities.

Full Analysis

Debate

Two AI advocates debated this claim using the research gathered.

Argument for

P
Proponent Argues TRUE

Multiple highly authoritative sources confirm that the Law of Attraction is a rebranding of older traditions: Source 1 (National Geographic) explicitly links it to the 19th-century New Thought movement and Hindu philosophy and Hermetic texts, Source 5 (Wikipedia) confirms roots in Hermeticism, Hinduism, and New England transcendentalism, and Source 11 traces it further back to Ancient Greek philosophy (Plato's 'law of affinity') and Hermetic teachings, while Source 25 (USA TODAY) directly states it has 'origins as far back as Hindu scriptures and Buddhism.' The mainstream breakthrough via The Secret is equally well-documented: Sources 3 (Reuters), 4 (New York Times), 7, 9, and 18 all confirm that Rhonda Byrne's 2006 book sold tens of millions of copies and, boosted by Oprah Winfrey's endorsement, propelled the Law of Attraction into mainstream popular culture in the 2000s.

O
Opponent Rebuttal

The Proponent commits a fallacy of division by conflating the modern, highly commercialized Law of Attraction with ancient, distinct spiritual traditions like Hinduism and Buddhism, which are only loosely linked through modern, eclectic synthesis rather than direct historical continuation as shown in Source 11 and Source 14. Furthermore, the Proponent's argument fails to recognize that the mainstream breakthrough in the 2000s was not achieved by the book The Secret in isolation, but was fundamentally driven by the massive promotional engine of The Oprah Winfrey Show as documented in Source 7 and Source 9.

Argument against

O
Opponent Argues FALSE

The claim that the modern Law of Attraction is a historical rebranding of ancient traditions is misleading, as the concept's core formulation actually originated as a distinct 19th-century American metaphysical belief system rather than a direct continuation of ancient philosophies. Furthermore, attributing its mainstream rise to the 2006 book The Secret overlooks the fact that its widespread 21st-century popularization was heavily driven by massive promotional campaigns on The Oprah Winfrey Show, as detailed in Source 7 and Source 9.

P
Proponent Rebuttal

The Opponent commits a false dichotomy by framing the 19th-century New Thought movement as an alternative to ancient philosophical roots rather than recognizing it as an intermediate link in a continuous chain of influence — Source 1 (National Geographic) explicitly states that New Thought 'drew direct influence from Hindu philosophy' and Hermetic texts, while Source 5 (Wikipedia) confirms roots in 'Hermeticism, New England transcendentalism, and Hinduism,' meaning the ancient origins and the New Thought formulation are complementary, not contradictory. Furthermore, the Opponent's attempt to diminish The Secret's role by crediting Oprah Winfrey's promotional platform actually reinforces rather than undermines the claim, as Sources 3, 4, 7, and 9 all treat Oprah's endorsement as a mechanism through which The Secret achieved mainstream reach — the book and its promotion are inseparable parts of the same 2006 mainstream breakthrough the claim describes.


Panel Review

3 specialized AI experts evaluated the evidence and arguments.

Reviewer 1 — The Logic Examiner

Focus: Inferential Soundness & Fallacies
Mostly True
8/10

Sources 1, 5, 12, and 14 support an inference that the modern Law of Attraction/manifesting is a contemporary repackaging that draws on older strands (especially New Thought plus Hindu-influenced and Western esoteric/Hermetic themes), while sources 3 and 4 directly support that Byrne's 2006 The Secret helped propel the idea into mainstream culture in the 2000s. However, the evidence pool does not logically establish the specific inclusion of Ancient Greek philosophy and Buddhism as major inputs (those links are comparatively indirect/interpretive in sources like 11 and 25), so the claim is directionally correct but somewhat over-extended in its breadth of asserted traditions.

Logical fallacies

Some supporting arguments risk a composition fallacy by treating thematic resemblance to Ancient Greek or Buddhist ideas as sufficient to prove a strong genealogical influence on the modern Law of Attraction.Some supporting arguments risk a hasty generalization by elevating weaker, more interpretive sources about Greek and Buddhist roots into the same evidentiary tier as the stronger New Thought and The Secret mainstreaming evidence.
Confidence: 7/10

Reviewer 2 — The Source Auditor

Focus: Source Reliability & Independence
True
9/10

High-authority independent sources such as National Geographic (Source 1), Reuters (Source 3), New York Times (Source 4), Encyclopaedia Britannica (Source 12), and Cambridge Dictionary (Source 14) confirm both the historical roots in New Thought plus Hindu, Hermetic, Greek, and Buddhist traditions and the 2000s mainstreaming via The Secret. Lower-authority sources add detail but do not alter the consensus from the most reliable ones.

Weakest sources

Source 26 is unreliable because it is a Reddit post with no independent verification.Source 28 is unreliable because it is a Reddit post consisting of personal anecdotes rather than evidence.Source 22 is unreliable because it is the official promotional site for The Secret and has a direct commercial interest in the claim.
Confidence: 9/10

Reviewer 3 — The Precision Analyst

Focus: Claim Precision & Quantitative Accuracy
True
10/10

The claim's assertion that the Law of Attraction is a rebranding of older traditions (including Ancient Greek philosophy, Hinduism, Buddhism, Hermeticism, and New Thought) is directly supported by Sources 1, 5, 11, 12, and 25, while its mainstream popularization in the 2000s via the 2006 book 'The Secret' is verified by Sources 3, 4, 7, and 9. The opponent's argument that Oprah Winfrey's promotion was the true driver does not invalidate the claim, as her promotion was the direct vehicle for the book's massive success.

Confidence: 10/10

Panel summary

See the full panel summary

Create a free account to read the complete analysis.

Sign up free
The claim is
Mostly True
8/10
Confidence: 9/10 Spread: 2 pts

Your annotation will be visible after submission.

Embed this verification

Every embed carries schema.org ClaimReview microdata — recognized by Google and AI crawlers.

Mostly True · Lenz Score 8/10 Lenz
“The modern concept known as the Law of Attraction is a rebranding that draws heavily from older philosophical and spiritual traditions, including Ancient Greek philosophy, Hinduism and Buddhism, Hermetic philosophy, and the 19th-century New Thought movement, and it became mainstream in the 2000s partly through the 2006 book The Secret.”
28 sources · 3-panel audit · Verified Jul 2026
See full report on Lenz →