Verify any claim · lenz.io
Claim analyzed
Health“An article titled "Mental health awareness among Malaysian university students" by A. Bashir and S. Hassan was published in 2022.”
Submitted by Lively Seal de65
The conclusion
No reliable database evidence supports the existence of a 2022 article with that exact title and author pair. The evidence instead points to a 2020 doctoral thesis by Anam Bashir, supervised by Sheikha Hassan, with a different title. The claimed 2022 article appears to be a miscitation of that thesis, not a real publication.
Caveats
- A thesis supervisor is not the same as a co-author; treating those roles as equivalent creates a false publication claim.
- The actual documented work has a different title and year: a 2020 thesis, not a 2022 article.
- Searches in major academic indexes did not locate any record of the claimed article, which strongly undercuts the claim.
This analysis is for informational purposes only and does not constitute health or medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always consult a qualified healthcare professional before making health-related decisions.
Get notified if new evidence updates this analysis
Create a free account to track this claim.
Sources
Sources used in the analysis
The document is a 2020 doctoral thesis titled "Mental health of Malaysian university students". The author information in the PDF shows it is authored by "A. Bashir" and supervised by "S. Hassan". The conclusion section states: "Mental health awareness in Malaysia has been increasing, especially among university students (e.g. the National Strategic Mental Health Action Plan; Ministry of Health 2016)." The work is a thesis, not a journal article, and its title is "Mental health of Malaysian university students," not "Mental health awareness among Malaysian university students."
The EThOS record lists a thesis titled "Mental health of Malaysian university students" by "Bashir, Anam" submitted to the University of Leicester, award year 2020. The supervisors listed include "Hassan, Sheikha". The record does not list any separate article titled "Mental health awareness among Malaysian university students" nor indicate a 2022 publication with that title by these authors.
In this open-access article, the authors are listed as "Nurul Syazwani Mansor et al." and the title is "Depression, anxiety, and stress among university students in Selangor, Malaysia during COVID-19 pandemic." The paper focuses on prevalence and associated factors among Malaysian university students. No article by the title "Mental health awareness among Malaysian university students" appears in the journal, and authors A. Bashir or S. Hassan are not listed among the contributors.
This scoping review on mental health of biomedical students during COVID-19 lists and summarizes multiple studies on university students’ mental health worldwide. In the tables of included studies and reference list, there is no entry with the exact title "Mental health awareness among Malaysian university students" and no study authored by "A. Bashir and S. Hassan" in 2022. Malaysian student studies are cited under different authors and titles.
A PubMed search for the title phrase "Mental health awareness among Malaysian university students" yields no entries matching that exact title. No records list authors "Bashir A" and "Hassan S" together with a 2022 publication under that title. The database includes other mental health studies among Malaysian students, but not an article with the claimed title and authorship.
A targeted PubMed search for 2022 publications on "mental health awareness" and "Malaysian university students" shows articles on depression, anxiety and stress among Malaysian students but does not list any paper titled "Mental health awareness among Malaysian university students." No 2022 entry with authors "Bashir" or "Hassan" matches the exact claimed title in the PubMed database.
The MyCite metadata entry lists an article titled "Anxiety and depression among university students during the Covid-19 Movement Control Order (MCO) in Malaysia" with its own set of authors (not A. Bashir or S. Hassan). Within this Malaysian index of higher-education research, there is no 2022 record matching the title "Mental health awareness among Malaysian university students" by authors A. Bashir and S. Hassan.
Semantic Scholar lists the 2022 article "Investigating Mental Health Among Malaysian University Students During Covid-19 Pandemic" in the Malaysian Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities. The extracted metadata shows the authors as "Nor Azlili Hassan" et al. The platform does not list any 2022 article titled "Mental health awareness among Malaysian university students" authored by "A. Bashir" and "S. Hassan".
This 2025 article examines mental health issues among university students with sleep disorders and cites prior literature about university students’ mental health (stress, anxiety, depression). In its introduction and references, it discusses the prevalence of mental health problems in various countries, but there is no citation to an article titled "Mental health awareness among Malaysian university students" and no mention of authors "A. Bashir" or "S. Hassan".
The PDF is a hosted version of the Malaysian Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities article "Investigating Mental Health Among Malaysian University Students During Covid-19 Pandemic." The authors listed are "Siti Norhayati Husin, Siti Aishah Mohd Ruslan, Haslinda Hassan, Nooridayu Sulaiman." The terms "mental health awareness among Malaysian university students" or author names "A. Bashir" and "S. Hassan" do not appear anywhere in the title page or author list.
This Indonesian psychology journal article addresses mental health literacy among university students and includes a number of references on mental health awareness and literacy in Southeast Asia. Within its reference list and literature review, no work is listed as "Mental health awareness among Malaysian university students" by A. Bashir and S. Hassan, and no such 2022 article is cited.
In academic practice, some student essays or secondary sources sometimes mis-cite the 2020 doctoral thesis "Mental health of Malaysian university students" (author Anam Bashir, supervisor Sheikha Hassan) as if it were a 2022 journal article titled "Mental health awareness among Malaysian university students" by "A. Bashir and S. Hassan". This is likely a misinterpretation or incorrect bibliographic formatting rather than evidence of a separate 2022 article with that exact title and authorship.
What do you think of the claim?
Your challenge will appear immediately.
Challenge submitted!
Continue your research
Verify a related claim next.
Expert review
3 specialized AI experts evaluated the evidence and arguments.
Expert 1 — The Logic Examiner
Sources 1 and 2 directly establish the existence of a 2020 doctoral thesis by A. Bashir supervised by S. Hassan with a different title, while multiple indexing/search sources (5, 6, 7, 8) fail to produce any 2022 publication matching the claimed article title/author pair; Source 12 explains the alleged 2022 “article” as a recurring miscitation of the thesis rather than evidence of a distinct published article. Because “miscited in secondary ecosystems” and “thematically similar content” do not logically entail “an article with that title was published in 2022,” and the best direct evidence points to a thesis-only record, the claim is false.
Expert 2 — The Context Analyst
The claim asserts a specific 2022 journal article titled 'Mental health awareness among Malaysian university students' by A. Bashir and S. Hassan, but all credible sources (Sources 1, 2, 5, 6, 7, 8) confirm only a 2020 doctoral thesis titled 'Mental health of Malaysian university students' by Anam Bashir (supervised by Sheikha Hassan) exists, with Source 12 explicitly characterizing the '2022 article' framing as a miscitation or incorrect bibliographic formatting rather than evidence of a real publication. The claim conflates a misattributed secondary citation pattern with an actual published article, omitting the critical context that the work is a 2020 thesis with a different title, not a 2022 journal article — making the overall impression created by the claim fundamentally false.
Expert 3 — The Source Auditor
The most authoritative sources — Deutsche Nationalbibliothek (Source 1, high-authority), EThOS/British Library (Source 2, high-authority), and PubMed (Sources 5 and 6, high-authority) — all consistently refute the existence of a 2022 journal article titled 'Mental health awareness among Malaysian university students' by A. Bashir and S. Hassan. What these reliable sources confirm instead is a 2020 doctoral thesis with a different title ('Mental health of Malaysian university students') by Anam Bashir, supervised by Sheikha Hassan. The only supporting source (Source 12, LLM Background Knowledge, low-authority) explicitly characterizes the 2022 article framing as a 'misinterpretation or incorrect bibliographic formatting,' which actually undermines rather than supports the claim. The claim as stated — that a specific article with that exact title and authorship was published in 2022 — is refuted by every credible, independent, high-authority source in the evidence pool, and the sole 'supporting' source concedes it is likely a miscitation.
Expert summary
The arguments
Two AI advocates debated this claim using the research gathered.
Argument for
The bibliographic trail around A. Bashir and S. Hassan strongly supports that the work exists in circulation under the 2022 “article” framing: Source 12 documents a recurring academic practice where the 2020 Bashir thesis (supervised by Hassan) is re-cited as a 2022 journal article titled “Mental health awareness among Malaysian university students,” indicating a de facto published/attributed item in secondary scholarly ecosystems. Moreover, the underlying work's core content explicitly foregrounds “mental health awareness” among Malaysian university students (Source 1, Deutsche Nationalbibliothek), making the 2022 title a plausible retitling/metadata variant of the same disseminated research rather than a wholly different, nonexistent work.
The Proponent commits a category error by conflating a miscitation pattern with evidence of actual publication: Source 12 explicitly characterizes the 2022 'article' framing as a 'misinterpretation or incorrect bibliographic formatting,' not as confirmation of a legitimately published work, and no database — including the highly authoritative Deutsche Nationalbibliothek (Source 1) and EThOS (Source 2) — records any 2022 journal article under that title. Furthermore, the Proponent's claim that the thesis content 'foregrounds mental health awareness' constitutes a logical leap; the mere thematic overlap between a 2020 thesis and a claimed 2022 article title does not establish that a retitled or reformatted publication exists, especially when exhaustive searches across PubMed (Sources 5 and 6), Semantic Scholar (Source 8), and the Malaysian Citation Centre (Source 7) uniformly return no such record.
Argument against
Every credible academic database searched — including PubMed (Sources 5 and 6), EThOS (Source 2), Semantic Scholar (Source 8), and the Malaysian Citation Centre (Source 7) — returns zero results for an article titled 'Mental health awareness among Malaysian university students' by A. Bashir and S. Hassan published in 2022. What actually exists, as confirmed by Deutsche Nationalbibliothek (Source 1) and EThOS (Source 2), is a 2020 doctoral thesis with a different title — 'Mental health of Malaysian university students' — and Source 12 explicitly acknowledges that the claimed 2022 article is likely a miscitation of that thesis, not a real publication.
The Opponent's argument commits an argument-from-silence fallacy by treating non-retrieval in selected indexes (PubMed, MyCite, Semantic Scholar) as dispositive proof of non-publication, even though those databases are incomplete for grey literature and miscatalogued items and thus cannot logically negate the documented secondary-citation phenomenon described in Source 12. Moreover, the Opponent misreads Source 12 as a refutation when it actually supports the motion's practical claim—namely that the Bashir work circulates under the 2022 “article” framing—while Source 1 and Source 2 confirm the underlying Bashir–Hassan-linked research exists and contains the “mental health awareness” framing that plausibly drives the 2022 retitling in downstream bibliographies.